Social-Networking Classes
Social Networking in Schools September 18th, 2007An interesting post titled “Facebook: cyber-suburbia” popped up on Google Reader today from the blog “Social Creature.” It makes the statement that Facebook has become a social-suburbia in comparison to Myspace. “You have to be kidding me,” I thought. See I am not a very big fan of the ongoing “battle” between the two sites; it gets a little annoying sometimes. But as I kept reading I began to see the issues that this social separation might cause in schools. The post claims that Myspace is a site for the freaks and geeks, the burnouts and queers, for the “teens who plan on going into the military after school,” for the “kids who are socially ostracized at school.” Facebook then is the site for the “jocks, athletes, or other “good” kids.”
After reading this I asked myself what this meant for a teen’s experience at school. Immediately I though back to the day when you walk down the hallway to your locker and along the way are the group of jocks standing in their jerseys, the good looking girls looking, well, good, the burnouts sitting in the corner, or the smart kids studying away. This vast range of clicks can be hard on a student who does not fit in, a new student or someone who wants to be a part of two groups. Wow I thought, now students can’t leave this at the door when they leave school, it follows then home to their computer where they join groups, tag photos, write posts and messages, and list their favorite music and movies. This means that students will feel the pressure to define themselves in every way possible. The movies they like, the music they have playing, the pictures they have, the number of online friends they have all will contribute to define their social status and group. I will be blunt when I say this is not only terrible for the generations to come, but it is purely pathetic.
So what does this all mean? Is it really all that big of a deal or is it just going to be another aspect of the teenager’s society that is sometimes hard to understand when looking back. Well I believe that this social labeling that the two sites have created is a big deal and it will only separate students even more in the hallways. “Oh don’t talk to him, he is a Myspace creep,” or “there goes the Facebook jock, what a prep!” Teenagers have it hard enough trying to fit in and deal with criticism at school no matter how popular they are. Their lives and popularity should not be defined by their Myspace or Facebook page that is too superficial for even middle schools and high schools.
Source: Social Creature (blog)
Author: Jenks
Title: Facebook: Cyber-suburbia
September 18th, 2007 at 4:06 pm
Hi Tyler,
I really liked your entry that you chose to write about for this article. While it is unfortunate that socialization has shifted from in person to behind a computer monitor, it’s the truth, and as you pointed out, students are already having a hard time dealing with issues regarding school; why should they have to deal with this, too?
The problems of myspace and facebook have always been in the media once the craze hit, but people don’t generally look at the idea of a regular student’s insecurities they may face due to these social networking websites while trying to cope with school. Thanks for pointing that out!
September 21st, 2007 at 3:54 pm
Hi Tyler,
This is a really interesting topic that you’ve chosen for your project because obviously, the use of the internet and its features has become popular in all forms of our culture. This means that it has in schools as well. It is unfortunate that these great resources are being used for negative purposes. In other words, long live the “cliques.” This portion of high school seems to be something that lives on no matter what the decade is. It is also sad that students are willing to make this social network a way of slamming other people. This is another reason that so many media sources are talking about the negative effects of this tool. But regardless, I still feel that there are many beneficial reasons to use these websites. I have seen several presentations on how these can be used in literature classes and I personally think that Myspace and Facebook is revolutionary in how we think about books and the aspects composed of them. In addition to this, students can be assigned various writing assignments through the websites. So I think that in spite of the fact that yes, students use these for negative reasons, there can also be useful tasks which can be completed for academic purposes. But regardless, I think this topic is important and I look forward to reading about other articles you’ve found.
September 24th, 2007 at 9:24 pm
Tyler,
I also read an article about facebook and myspace. The article I read said similar things about the people who join facebook and the people who join myspace. It stated things like those on facebook are smarter and more likely to go to college than those on myspace. When I read it I just laughed and I joked to my friend that I must be smart because I have an account on facebook. What your post made me think about was how this type of labeling would effect a teen, especially because I have a brother in ninth grade and he is on facebook as well. I can see how these sites could be driving people apart instead of bringing them together. And I think that is unfortunate.
September 25th, 2007 at 12:07 am
What an interesting topic. I agree with Sarah. It is so sad that these so-called “social networking sites” are driving students apart. Isn’t the point of Myspace and Facebook to be able to network with your friends? It is not supposed to be a forum for students to label and exclude each other even more than they already do in school. The great thing about all the drama of middle school and high school is that at the end of the day, you can go home and escape it all. But when students have the ability to go online and have networks of their cliques, it just serves as a constant reminder to everyone of their social status. I think that this would just fuel the insecurities that are already too common at this age. Myspace and Facebook can be a lot of fun if their users use them for good purposes and do not get out of control with labeling and clique-iness.
September 25th, 2007 at 12:49 pm
I think this is an interesting subject. Besides being grounds for some healthy competition among scholars, in today’s busy world it allows members of the site to network. I think this also plays a big role in my favorite extra-curricular activity: multi-tasking! I can’t wait for my publicity on this site. Thanks for letting us know about it!
October 23rd, 2007 at 3:13 pm
[...] here are my three replies: Tyler, Eli, [...]
November 27th, 2007 at 1:16 pm
[...] comment on Tyler’s [...]
December 1st, 2007 at 11:45 pm
[...] blog Chris’s blog Rachel’s blog Tyler’s blog Nathan’s blog Hilary’s blog Jana’s blog: [...]
December 4th, 2007 at 1:15 am
[...] Tyler [...]
December 4th, 2007 at 1:19 am
[...] Tyler’s Blog [...]